Caleigh was Jeff Award nominated for Best Supporting Actor in a Musical for her portrayal of Evelyn Williams in Kokandys Production of American Psycho the Musical

AMERICAN PSYCHO REVIEWS

As far as performances go, the real MVP was Caleigh Pan-Kita’s Evelyn. Portraying Bateman’s materialistic and clueless girlfriend, she stole the show in every scene and played very well off Kyle Patrick’s deadpan approach.
Caleigh Pan-Kita (“ Chorus Line” at Drury Lane) is flawless as Evelyn Williams, Patrick’s equally shallow, status-obsessed girlfriend. Ms. Pan-Kita can sing, move and deliver her character’s banal lines with much aplomb.
Caleigh Pan-Kita is sublime as Patrick’s ditzy, delusional girlfriend Evelyn; Pan-Kita’s decision to make Evelyn a real caricature works incredibly well
Complementing Bateman’s unreality is the magnificent Caleigh Pan-Kita as Evelyn Williams. Pan-Kita is an unrivaled character actress that brings refreshing levity to every scene she steals. The frenetic sociopathy she brings to Patrick’s psychopathy is a match made in heaven…or hell in this case..
Caleigh Pan-Kita equally dazzles as Patrick’s Barbie Gone Bad girlfriend Evelyn Williams.

A Chorus Line Reviews

Of course, one of the best known numbers from this show is “Dance:Ten;Looks Three” and Val Caleigh Pan-Kita) is perfect.
Caleigh Pan-Kita nearly stole the show as wannabe Rockette Val who shares how cosmetic surgery helped her get hired in the delicious “Dance Ten Looks Three.”